188. " and do not devour your property among yourselves by
wrongful
means, nor offer it as a bribe to judges, with intent that you may unlawfully
swallow up a portion of other people's property, while you know."
commentary:
this verse prohibits muslims from
committing a very indecent
action. it tells them not to swallow up the property of other people
unrightfully, and not to earn wealth through a wrong way. they should
be aware not to occupy the belongings of others forcefully and unjustly
and then the oppressors refer to the judges so that haply they might give
them something as a present or bribe in order to appropriate people's
properties oppressively. if so, they have done two great wrongs:
devouring others' rights, and bribery.
" and do not devour your property among yourselves by
wrongful means,
nor offer it as a bribe to judges, that you may unlawfully swallow up a
portion of other people's property, while you know."
the subject of bribery is so important in
islam that imam sadiq
(a.s.) says about it:
"...and bribery in judgement is the same as disbelief in allah, the exalted." 1
the holy prophet (p.b.u.h.) is narrated to
have said in a famous
tradition:
" curse of allah be upon the bribee, the briber and
the one who makes every
effort between them." 2
something similar to this meaning is
expressed in sura
an-nisa'. no. 4, verse 29 where it says: " ... do not devour your
property among yourselves falsely, except that it be trading by your mutual
consent, ..."
the verse under discussion clearly says that if some ones gain a
case by giving bribes, the wealth under the suit which they win will be
unlawful for them. thus, the mere apparent winning in the court does
not make the properties lawful. this very fact is clearly referred to in a
tradition from the holy prophet (p.b.u.h.) where it says: " verily, i am a
human being (who is commissioned to judge between you through apparent
means). if a conflict comes forth to me in which some of you may have
stronger evidence than that of the other party, then i will judge in favour
of
him according to it. so, if i thereby judge for him upon the right of a
muslim, it is a piece of fire. he can take it or leave it off." 3
bribery, a calamity
one of the calamities that
humankind had been entangled with
from the earliest times, and which is running with a more intense speed
today, is bribery. it has been one of the greatest barriers of the
execution of social justice. it causes that the regulations and laws, which
must basically preserve the rights of the oppressed groups, to be
employed, in most societies, to support the interests of the authoritative
groups.
it is the rights of the weak, in fact, that law must support, for the
rich and powerful people, with the possibilities they have, are always
capable to defend their benefits. evidently, if the path of bribery be
opened, laws and judges may produce just a contrary result, because it is
usually the powerful ones who are able to spend in bribery. therefore,
as a consequence, laws can be a new toy for them to continue their
satanic game of transgression and cruelty against the rights of the
oppressed.
for this reason, when bribery influences in a society, it destroys
the foundation of the social life of those people. in this situation,
transgression, inequity, injustice and undue distinction penetrate in all
organs and, as a result, there remains but a bare name of laws and
justice.
that is why islam, showing the foulness of bribery, has condemned
it intensely so that it has been counted a great sin in the view of the
religion.
it is worthy noting that the ugliness of this indecent action is often
covered in some other fallacious arguments and charming terms. this
status causes that bribers and bribees usually make use of words such as:
present, offering, dedication, tip, reward, recompense, and so on, for the
bribe. but it is clear that these variations of names do not change the
nature of bribery at all, and, however the money paid or taken thereby is
certainly unlawful (haram).
it is cited in nahjul-balaqah that ash`ath-ibn-qays went to
ali-ibn-ali-talib (a.s.) in a night with a closed flask full of honey paste
to give it to him (a.s) as a present hoping that he would win the case in
the court of hadrat ali (a.s.). but ali (a.s.) surprised and violately said:
" childless women may weep over you. have you come to
deviate me from
the religion of allah, ...? "
" by allah, even if i am given all the domains of the seven (stars) with
all that exits under the skies in order that i may disobey allah to the
extent
of snatching one grain of barley from an ant, i would not do it. for me,
your world is lighter than the leaf in the mouth of a locust that is chewing
it.
what has `ali to do with bounties that will pass away and pleasures that will
not last? ..." 4
islam has condemned bribery in any form
and by any name. it is
narrated in the history of the life of the prophet of islam (p.b.u.h.) that
once he was informed that one of his governor-generals had received a
bribe in the form of a present. then the prophet (p.b.u.h.) harshly told
him:
" why do you take the thing which is not your right? "
then the man, apologizing to him
(p.b.u.h.), said that it was a
present. again, the prophet (p.b.u.h.) expressed:
" if you were to remain at home while you were not a
governor from my side,
would people present you with anything? " 5
then, the prophet (p.b.u.h.) ordered the present
to be taken and
be sent inside the muslim public treasury, when he dismissed him from
his rank.
even, in order that a judge would not confront with bribery in its
hidden shapes, islam advises that judges would not go shopping in the
market themselves, lest discounts unconsciously affect on them and,
when judging the suit, they eventually take the side of the giver of the
reduction.
how good it is that muslims, inspired by their heavenly book, do
not sacrifice all their holy things at the foot of bribery!
it is also said that the purpose of the verse is that they do not
spend the wealth and properties of each other by means of vain
pleasures like gambling or other games.
it is narrated from imam sadiq (a.s.) who said: " the quraish used
to play games upon their wives, children, and personal wealth, losing them.
allah prohibited them of doing that." 6
it is better to consider all of these commentaries for the verse,
because it can bear the meanings of them all totally.